Drone Loans: Customs and Border Protection Records 500 Predator Flights for Other Agencies

EFF Lawsuit Uncovers Abuse Of Surveillance Drones; DHS Files Motion To Suppress Further Transparency

drone loans

Customs & Border Protection released a new list to EFF this week that details the extensive number of times that the agency has flown its Predator drones on behalf of other agencies—500 flights in total over a three-year period. This list shows, yet again, how little we know about drone flights in this country and how important it is that we place limits on drone use to protect Americans’ privacy rights.

EFF obtained the list of federal, state and local agencies as a result of our Freedom of Information Act lawsuit against the agency. Not only does the list show the total number of flights by year between 2010 and 2012, but it shows CBP flew its drones over 100 times just for Department of Justice components including FBI, DEA and US Marshals. This is in direct contradiction to a recently released DOJ Office of Inspector General (OIG) Report (pdf) that stated DHS had flown its drones on only two occasions for DOJ law enforcement components.

EFF discussed some of the other agencies that benefited from CBP’s Predators in a previous post, but some agencies on the list are new. These include the Grand Forks SWAT, the North Dakota Narcotics Task Force, the Bureau of Indian Affairs, the Arizona Department of Public Safety, the Minnesota Drug Task Force, and several branches of the military.

The list also includes several county sheriff’s departments. However, CBP has refused to release the names of these agencies, arguing in a recent court filing that to do so would disclose secret law enforcement techniques and would somehow “reveal that CBP is aware of the illegal activities taking place in a particular location.” It’s hard to fathom how releasing the name of a county sheriff department—without any other information about the drone flight for that department—would somehow let the criminals in the area know they’re being watched and help them evade detection.


Even after all the attention drone surveillance has garnered in the US, CBP has yet to establish rules for its drone flights that would protect Americans’ privacy rights. In the report on the DOJ’s drone use, the Inspector General severely chastised DOJ for similarly failing to implement privacy-protecting rules—and for willfully failing to recognize that drone surveillance raises privacy issues different from surveillance with manned aircraft. The OIG recognized what EFF has been saying all along—that the advanced technological capabilities of drones, their low operational costs as compared to manned aircraft, and their ability to conduct “pervasive tracking of an individual’s movements” whether on “public or private property “ raise “unique concerns about privacy and the collection of evidence.”

We welcome the Inspector General’s investigation of DOJ drone use and hope the same will happen within the Department of Homeland Security—and within CBP in particular. We also encourage the agencies to follow the OIG’s recommendation to convene a working group to address the privacy risks and establish explicit agency-wide rules to protect individual privacy interests.

EFF v. DHS – Customs & Border Protection’s Motion for …

CBP.gov – home page


Includes the former Border Patrol and Customs Service. Missions include detecting and preventing the illegal entry of persons and goods into the country.

Written testimony of CBP for a Senate Homeland Security …


Written testimony of CBP Office of Border Patrol Chief Patrol Agent-Havre Sector, Christopher Richards for a Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental …



EFF. DATE 08/17/2010 70050800 DC 20229 2. AMENDMENT/MODIFICATION NO. … DHSCustoms & Border Protection Department of Homeland Security 1300 Pennsylvania Ave, NW


Customs & Border Protection Logged Eight-Fold Increase in Drone Surveillance for Other Agencies

Customs & Border Protection Considered Weaponizing Drones

Do we need more drones at the border? “Q: So… – Border Fact Check

EFF Lawsuit Uncovers Abuse Of Surveillance Drones; DHS Files

One thought on “Drone Loans: Customs and Border Protection Records 500 Predator Flights for Other Agencies

  1. Pingback: Leery drone-zone denizens convene in Julian | Back Country Voices

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s